Neal Martin is a senior editor at Vinous, where his coverage includes Bordeaux, Burgundy, South Africa and New Zealand. Before joining Vinous, he wrote for Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate. His detailed tasting notes and candid opinions have made him a familiar reference for wine drinkers following the Cape.
In 2020, he was named Best Wine Critic of the World in the BWW competition. His reviews look at the wine in the glass and its prospects in the cellar, giving readers a description to consider alongside the score.
His 2026 reviews brought strong results across the Ex Animo portfolio. Van Loggerenberg’s Graft Syrah 2025 received 98 points, while Scions of Sinai’s Swanesang Syrah 2025 and Van Loggerenberg’s Lötter Cinsaut and High Hopes Syrah 2025 each received 96.
Below is the full list of 90+ wines in our compiled portfolio results, with producer graphics and links to individual wines, followed by our twelve-bottle mixed case. The scores include wines outside the case, auction bottlings and older vintages reviewed this year.
Twelve South African wines from six producers, each awarded 90 points or more by Neal Martin of Vinous.
This mixed case brings together six whites and six reds from Beeslaar, Thorne & Daughters, Scions of Sinai, Van Loggerenberg, Saurwein and Trizanne Signature Wines. Leading the selection is Van Loggerenberg’s 98-point Graft Syrah 2025.
The whites range from aromatic Riesling and Grenache Blanc to textured Chenin Blanc, Chardonnay and old-vine Sémillon. The reds offer Cinsaut, Cabernet Franc, Pinot Noir, Nebbiolo and two contrasting Syrahs.
Neal Martin’s 90+ Scoring Wines | 2026
Neal Martin is a senior editor at Vinous, where his coverage includes Bordeaux, Burgundy, South Africa and New Zealand. Before joining Vinous, he wrote for Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate. His detailed tasting notes and candid opinions have made him a familiar reference for wine drinkers following the Cape.
In 2020, he was named Best Wine Critic of the World in the BWW competition. His reviews look at the wine in the glass and its prospects in the cellar, giving readers a description to consider alongside the score.
His 2026 reviews brought strong results across the Ex Animo portfolio. Van Loggerenberg’s Graft Syrah 2025 received 98 points, while Scions of Sinai’s Swanesang Syrah 2025 and Van Loggerenberg’s Lötter Cinsaut and High Hopes Syrah 2025 each received 96.
Below is the full list of 90+ wines in our compiled portfolio results, with producer graphics and links to individual wines, followed by our twelve-bottle mixed case. The scores include wines outside the case, auction bottlings and older vintages reviewed this year.
Neal Martin 90+ | Twelve-Bottle Mixed Case
R5,305.00Original price was: R5,305.00.R5,039.75Current price is: R5,039.75.Twelve South African wines from six producers, each awarded 90 points or more by Neal Martin of Vinous.
This mixed case brings together six whites and six reds from Beeslaar, Thorne & Daughters, Scions of Sinai, Van Loggerenberg, Saurwein and Trizanne Signature Wines. Leading the selection is Van Loggerenberg’s 98-point Graft Syrah 2025.
The whites range from aromatic Riesling and Grenache Blanc to textured Chenin Blanc, Chardonnay and old-vine Sémillon. The reds offer Cinsaut, Cabernet Franc, Pinot Noir, Nebbiolo and two contrasting Syrahs.
Beeslaar
Pinotage 2024
93 points
Chardonnay 2025
92 points
Hearth
Swinsian Chardonnay 2024
92 points
Artjesvlei Pinot Noir 2024
90 points
Lourens Family Wines
Lindi Carien White Blend 2025
91 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Mathias Chenin Blanc 2025
94 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Lua Grenache Noir 2025
92 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Howard John Red Blend 2025
91+ points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Pieter Ferreira
Birdsong Blanc Extra Brut 2023
92 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Blanc de Blancs 2021
90 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Saurwein
Chi Riesling 2026
90 points
Nom Pinot Noir 2025
91 points
Boom Nebbiolo 2025
90 points
Scions of Sinai
Gramadoelas Grenache Blanc 2025
92 points
Granietsteen Chenin Blanc 2025
95 points
Heldervallei Cinsaut 2025
94 points
Krummelklip Cabernet Sauvignon 2025
91 points
Féniks Pinotage 2025
94 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Swanesang Syrah 2025
96 points
Reviewed vintage — shop listing not yet confirmed.
Thorne & Daughters
Paper Kite Old Vine Sémillon 2025
94 points
Snakes & Ladders Sauvignon Blanc 2025
93 points
Cat’s Cradle Chenin Blanc 2025
93 points
Tin Soldier Sémillon Gris 2025
91 points
Rocking Horse Cape White 2024
90+ points
Trizanne Signature Wines
Pinot Noir 2024
90 points
Elim Syrah 2024
90+ points
Trizanne Signature Wines | TSW
TSW Syrah 2024
92 points
Van Loggerenberg
Trust Your Gut Chenin Blanc 2025
93 points
Kameraderie Chenin Blanc 2025
92 points
Lötter Cinsaut 2025
96 points
Geronimo Cinsaut 2025
94 points
Breton Cabernet Franc 2025
95 points
High Hopes Syrah 2025
96 points
Graft Syrah 2025
98 points
Vulpes
Chama Chenin Blanc 2025
92+ points
Not released yet.
Additional scored wines
Beeslaar Pinotage (CWG) 2024 — 93 points
Pieter Ferreira Blanc de Noirs Pinot Noir (CWG) 2019 — 94 points
Solo Wines by Carl Schultz Auction Merlot (CWG) 2023 — 90 points
Thorne & Daughters Sand Castles (CWG) 2025 — 93 points
Thorne & Daughters Rocking Horse 2016 — 95 points
Van Loggerenberg Syrah (CWG) 2025 — 98 points
Van Loggerenberg Chenin Blanc (CWG) 2025 — 96 points
Van Loggerenberg Kameraderie 2016 — 94 points
THE NEAL MARTIN 90+ MIXED CASE